NSW Premier Chris Minns has abandoned sweeping real estate underquoting reforms at the eleventh hour, pulling back legislation just hours before it was due to come into force, in a dramatic reversal that has wasted millions of dollars in industry preparation and left thousands of agents scrambling. The about-face, triggered by concerns raised by agents in the Premier's own Kogarah electorate, has drawn fierce criticism and raised serious questions about the government's capacity to deliver meaningful housing reform.
What the Scrapped Underquoting Reforms Were Meant to Do
When Minns first announced the new underquoting laws roughly a year ago, they were billed as among the most significant reforms to the NSW real estate industry in decades. The package included a requirement that price guides appear on all property marketing materials, based on three comparable sales. Crucially, penalties for underquoting were set to increase dramatically, rising from $22,000 to $110,000, or three times an agent's commission, whichever figure was greater.
The reforms were a direct response to widespread and blatant underquoting uncovered through an 18-month investigation, which drew responses from more than 9,100 people across Victoria and NSW. The majority of those respondents reported spending significant time and money investigating properties they ultimately could not afford. Sydney has been identified as the underquoting capital of Australia, with almost half of all properties sold at auction fetching more than 10 per cent above the advertised guide price.
A Fatal Flaw Hidden in the Fine Print
Hidden within the legislation, however, was a provision that restricted agents from advertising a price below any written offer that had previously been rejected by a seller. In a rising market, this presents no particular difficulty. But in a falling market, the rule becomes a serious problem: sellers who had previously knocked back a higher written offer would be unable to revise their advertised price downward to reflect changed conditions.
The government had reportedly been warned on multiple occasions before the laws passed parliament in June that this clause risked unintended consequences. Better Regulation and Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong acknowledged on Monday night that the laws had been passed "at a different time and in a different economic and housing market," effectively conceding they were no longer fit for purpose.
Millions Wasted as Industry Left in Limbo
The fallout for the real estate industry has been immediate and significant. Agents across the state had spent months updating their business practices, marketing materials and compliance systems ahead of the midnight deadline.
Dan White, the head of Australia's largest real estate franchise Ray White Group, said the reversal came after an enormous effort by his organisation to prepare its members. "Over the past six months, our compliance team has run sessions with all 3,400 of our NSW members," White said. "We hired halls from Yamba to Orange to hold zone meetings across the state."
Ray White went further, building a real-time compliance platform called Stockboard, which scans residential sales listings and flags any that do not meet underquoting requirements. The platform is already operating in Victoria, where separate reforms rolled out in October now mandate an advertised reserve price at least one week before every auction.
The Only Winners: Agents Who Profit From Underquoting
Critics argue the only beneficiaries of the debacle are the thousands of agents who have long profited from deliberately low price guides. The scale of the problem is illustrated by the case of former sales agent Josh Tesolin, who received a decade-long ban from the industry and fines of $33,000 after being found to have engaged in sustained unlawful, improper and dishonest conduct across more than 100 property transactions.
As Sydney auctions continue in the weeks ahead, buyers face the same opaque environment the reforms were designed to fix. The government has offered no firm timeline for revised legislation, and trust in the state's capacity to deliver on this issue has taken a significant hit. The failed rollout has not only cost the industry dearly in time and money, it has handed a reprieve to exactly the practitioners the laws were designed to rein in.
